David Awoyode
Although summer isn’t officially over, Starbucks is bringing back its iconic Pumpkin Spice Latte (PSL) next week. First introduced in 2003, the PSL has become a seasonal staple and inspired many competing chains to launch their own pumpkin-flavored creations.
First Stop: Dutch Bros
I started my taste test at Dutch Bros, the Oregon-based drive-thru chain with more than 900 US locations. I ordered the Caramel Pumpkin Brûlée Breve, which cost $7.59 for a 24-ounce medium.
The drink didn’t have the classic pumpkin spice profile but delivered a subtle nuttiness and smooth caramel flavor. The sweetened cold foam added a creamy, autumnal touch, making it rich and satisfying.
Next Up: Starbucks
From Dutch Bros, I headed straight to Starbucks, where I picked up a 16-ounce iced Pumpkin Spice Latte for $7.21.
This version leaned heavily on warming spices, particularly allspice, and was topped with whipped cream and cinnamon. It had the strongest coffee flavor of the three drinks but also carried a slightly bitter aftertaste.
Final Stop: Dunkin’
Finally, I tried Dunkin’s Pumpkin Spice Iced Signature Latte, which cost $6.01 for a 24-ounce medium — the best value of the three.
The drink, however, tasted more like a chai latte due to its weaker espresso shot. The pumpkin-spice syrup was overly sweet, and the texture less creamy than the others. The thick whipped cream topping added some richness, but overall, the flavor missed the mark.
The Winner: Dutch Bros
Out of the three, Dutch Bros’ Caramel Pumpkin Brûlée Breve stood out as the winner. While it didn’t deliver the traditional pumpkin spice flavor, its unique smoky-caramel profile felt cozy and seasonal.
Starbucks’ PSL remained flavorful but a bit too bitter, while Dunkin’s latte leaned overly sweet and lacked balance
Charles Esther